Ali Cupper, ‘misrepresented’ and ‘gaslit’, shuns SOE Bill

MEMBER for Mildura Ali Cupper says she has been “gaslit” and “misrepresented by everybody” throughout her negotiations to gain concessions for regional Victoria within the State Government’s proposed nine-month state of emergency extension.

Ms Cupper and her Reason Party colleague Fiona Patten believed they had gained confirmation from the Labor Government that concessions for the regions in the future framework for managing the pandemic would be implemented before the Bill was voted on in the Upper House this week.

On the basis that the legislation was “nuanced, that has the right risk measures and calculations in it”, Ms Patten supported the extension, telling State Parliament that people in the Mallee could not understand why they had been included in a five-day lockdown under stage 4 restrictions last month.

Ms Patten said the government had confirmed there would be “some very specific regulations and information” about how regional areas were dealt with under the amendments.

But Health Minister Martin Foley on Wednesday stopped short of acknowledging any commitment to regional areas for concessions within the legislation.

Mr Foley said the government was unable to agree to the Reason Party’s proposed traffic-light system for how any public health and wellbeing restrictions were placed proportionately across regional Victoria.

“That proposal wasn’t worked up sufficiently enough,” he said.

“Let’s be clear: no commitment was given, even though a commitment was sought by the Reason Party.”

Ms Cupper said the denial came just a day after she had been told there would be concessions for the regions.

The Mildura MP late on Thursday voted against the amended Bill, minus regional concessions, in the Lower House.

Changes to the legislation included a reduction in fines for young people, a review of fines for disadvantaged communities, an appeal process for detention orders and the right for people to protest.

The legislation was passed by the Lower House.

Before the vote, Ms Cupper told parliament that claims by “the big parties” that she was trying to get regional Victoria permanently excluded from COVID-19 restrictions were incorrect.

“When I am trying to negotiate constructively with the government in good faith to get some reassurance for the regions on the state of emergency, I am gaslit and I am misrepresented by everybody,” Ms Cupper said.

“The big parties are spending time and money on deeply unfair and misleading and probably defamatory smear campaigns against me.

“While I am using my time and my electorate’s resources trying to get a new hospital, the big parties are spending tens of thousands of dollars on letterboxing blatant misinformation — and it is personal, and it is sexist — using awful photos to portray me as ugly and using sexualised language to humiliate my colleague Fiona Patten.

“The lies and the distortions feel beyond usual just politicking and political nitpicking.

“They are getting worse — they are breathtaking, and so is the hypocrisy.”

Digital Editions


  • Girl admits raft of offending

    Girl admits raft of offending

    A TEENAGE girl involved in multiple home invasions and thefts of vehicles with co-accused children aged as young as 11 might be permitted to return…

More News

  • Benham backs fire inquiry input

    Benham backs fire inquiry input

    SUBMISSIONS to a Victorian Parliamentary committee’s inquiry into the 2026 summer bushfires are now open, and a local politician is calling input from people in the region. Fires affected parts…

  • Students learn kindness is key

    Students learn kindness is key

    IRYMPLE Primary School students cemented their learning about kindness by making posters with powerful messages after a visit from the Pat Cronin Foundation last week. One-hundred and sixty children from…

  • Swan Hill train service still on track

    Swan Hill train service still on track

    THE future of the Swan Hill passenger train line is secured despite passengers being told by V/Line staff they could be ushered onto buses in the next 12 months. Passenger…

  • Group backs call for foster reforms

    Group backs call for foster reforms

    FRIDAY 20 February was World Care Day, which aims to raise awareness and celebrate children and young people in foster care, kinship or residential care. Mallee Family Care used the…

  • Play day at SMECC

    Play day at SMECC

    JUVELINA Guterres’ multilingualism comes in handy as the playgroup facilitator at Sunraysia Mallee Ethnic Council’s multicultural story time playgroup. On Monday and Wednesday mornings you’ll find Ms Guterres speaking English,…

  • Almond farm on the market

    Almond farm on the market

    THE Yarrum Agriculture Almond Aggregation at Red Cliffs has been listed for sale by CBRE Agribusiness, with an asking price of $19.5 and $21 million. It’s second time around for…

  • Sunraysia & District golf results

    Sunraysia & District golf results

    RIVERSIDE Sunday 15 February – medley stableford A Grade – 1st – Nicholas George 41 points, 2nd – Jason Zambelli 40 points C/B, 3rd – Brendan Rodgers 40 points. B…

  • Volunteers down to clean up

    Volunteers down to clean up

    CLEAN Up Australia Day, the largest environmental movement in the country will return this Sunday. According to Clean Up Australia’s 2024 financial year Litter Report, a snapshot of litter collected…

  • New Grey Wolf enters Scout pack

    New Grey Wolf enters Scout pack

    A THIRD-generation local member of the Scouting movement has earned the highest award available to a Cub. A dedicated Cub Scout for the past three years, 11-year-old Emmerson Munro has…

  • $32m plan for Mansell Reserve

    $32m plan for Mansell Reserve

    MILDURA councillors will this week consider a proposed $32 million revamp of the foundational home of women’s sport in the region. Councillors will be asked to endorse the Mansell Reserve…