Penalties for water breaches have to count

THE issue of water is simultaneously the most complicated and the most simple of all the issues that I deal with as an MP.

It is complicated because it is dripping in layers upon layers of rules and regulations that are in some cases more than a century old.

It is governed by multiple pieces of legislation across state and federal jurisdictions. Its politics is saturated in a wide array of disciplines – biology, physics, chemistry, engineering, economics, sociology and just about every branch of law you can think of.

But at the same time, it is simple. If we don’t have enough water at an affordable rate, our entire social and economic fabric will be changed irreparably.

Our family farmers who made this region, who live in the community, who send their kids to local schools, who shop at local shops, who contribute to our local charities and sporting clubs, will be crowded out of the game by a few deep- pocketed multinational corporations.

That’s why, in a crowded water market, there needs to be rules, to give everyone a fair shot at surviving and prospering in an increasingly competitive environment.

The Victorian Government claims to take a zero-tolerance approach to water theft. The maximum fine for water theft under the Victorian Water Act is $990,000.

But Brownport Almonds, a company that reportedly earns up to $100 million per season, was fined just $47,000 for 147 breaches of the Act.

Brownport’s excuse was that it was battling drought and high prices. Our family farmers are battling those same things, but they’re doing so within the rules.

The State Government might have upped the legislative penalties, but if a company like Brownport can get off the hook so lightly, there’s more work to do.

State Water Minister Lisa Neville heeded our calls for a moratorium on new plantings in our region. We were grateful for that. But her next task is to fix the legislation so that big companies who cheat cop a decent consequence.

Digital Editions


  • Tigers ready to pounce

    Tigers ready to pounce

    THE Red Cliffs A Grade netball team finished the season with a flurry last year, and after putting on the game of the year against…

More News

  • Pies new recruits help them fly

    Pies new recruits help them fly

    THE Merbein Football Club has a large bunch of loyal players and supporters, and although the team struggled on the scoreboard in 2025, co-coach Damien Hall said morale was high,…

  • Crazy hair for a worthy cause

    Crazy hair for a worthy cause

    COLOUR, laughter and a very brave haircut took over Ranfurly Primary School on Wednesday 1 April, as students and staff came together for Crazy Hair Day and Shave for a…

  • eSmart Week helps kids stay safe

    eSmart Week helps kids stay safe

    WITH technology constantly evolving and kids using digital devices from very young ages, it’s never been a better time to start the conversation around esafety. “There are a lot of…

  • Wenty seniors aim to emulate A-grade

    Wenty seniors aim to emulate A-grade

    WENTWORTH District Roos senior coach, Ben McGlynn, said he believes his players can match the 2025 success of Amanda Edwards’s netball team this coming season. The team had some injuries…

  • Bilbies making a big comeback

    Bilbies making a big comeback

    THE Mallee Cliffs National Park has contributed markedly to the largest population increase of Australia’s threatened greater bilby in recent years. Affectionately known as the Easter bilby, new data from…

  • Minister backs VFA on carp cull

    Minister backs VFA on carp cull

    THE shadow minister for agriculture, fisheries and forestry, Darren Chester, has supported the Victorian Fisheries Authority’s to release the carp herpes virus to help control the pest fish. Speaking in…

  • Ecstasy to agony: Levelling out the rollercoaster ride

    Ecstasy to agony: Levelling out the rollercoaster ride

    OUYEN United Kangas A Grade netball side went from remarkable champions to the bottom of the ladder in a 2025 season that simply did not go to plan. The Kangas…

  • Lives are at risk without a equipment: firefighter

    Lives are at risk without a equipment: firefighter

    AS a United Firefighters Union delegate and local firefighter at Fire Station 72 in Mildura, Luke Alexander, is used to being on the frontline. Mr Alexander has served for about…

  • History, travel, and intrigue

    History, travel, and intrigue

    Mildura libraries have wide range of titles in the collection, with new items continually being added. Here is a selection of some of the new additions that are available for…

  • Peeps into the Past – 29 March to 4 April: Waters steps in

    Peeps into the Past – 29 March to 4 April: Waters steps in

    PRESENTED by Mildura and District Historical Society amd compiled by Judy Hyde for Mildura Rural City Council Libraries. 100 YEARS AGO REGATTA: A year has passed since the first Henley…