Penalties for water breaches have to count

THE issue of water is simultaneously the most complicated and the most simple of all the issues that I deal with as an MP.

It is complicated because it is dripping in layers upon layers of rules and regulations that are in some cases more than a century old.

It is governed by multiple pieces of legislation across state and federal jurisdictions. Its politics is saturated in a wide array of disciplines – biology, physics, chemistry, engineering, economics, sociology and just about every branch of law you can think of.

But at the same time, it is simple. If we don’t have enough water at an affordable rate, our entire social and economic fabric will be changed irreparably.

Our family farmers who made this region, who live in the community, who send their kids to local schools, who shop at local shops, who contribute to our local charities and sporting clubs, will be crowded out of the game by a few deep- pocketed multinational corporations.

That’s why, in a crowded water market, there needs to be rules, to give everyone a fair shot at surviving and prospering in an increasingly competitive environment.

The Victorian Government claims to take a zero-tolerance approach to water theft. The maximum fine for water theft under the Victorian Water Act is $990,000.

But Brownport Almonds, a company that reportedly earns up to $100 million per season, was fined just $47,000 for 147 breaches of the Act.

Brownport’s excuse was that it was battling drought and high prices. Our family farmers are battling those same things, but they’re doing so within the rules.

The State Government might have upped the legislative penalties, but if a company like Brownport can get off the hook so lightly, there’s more work to do.

State Water Minister Lisa Neville heeded our calls for a moratorium on new plantings in our region. We were grateful for that. But her next task is to fix the legislation so that big companies who cheat cop a decent consequence.

Digital Editions


  • Musics best play Regfest

    Musics best play Regfest

    COUNTRY music is big in Sunraysia. And festival organisers Event People Australia, along with the Mildura Rural City Council, are capitalising on this by bringing…

More News

  • Living healthy

    Living healthy

    NEW items are constantly being added to our collection at the library. The following titles, covering a range of subjects, may be of interest to you. Cheese Magic Erika Kubick…

  • We found unity in extreme tragedy

    We found unity in extreme tragedy

    MY name is John Cortese. I was principal of Red Cliffs Secondary College from 1997 to 2008. It is completely understandable that this 20-year anniversary would stir so much emotion.…

  • Road safety is key

    Road safety is key

    Jade Benham Member for Mildura WHILE some may say the last 20 years have flown, for those affected by the Cardross Tragedy, every day has been a painful reminder of…

  • Longest Lunch Launched

    Longest Lunch Launched

    ROTARY Mildura Deakin are excited to announce the return of Mildura’s Longest Lunch on Friday 20 March, commencing at 12:00pm. Event Coordinator Tim Aldridge said the Longest Lunch had become…

  • Irish charm to hit Sunraysia

    Irish charm to hit Sunraysia

    IRELAND: The Voyage, which comes to Mildura Arts Centre on Thursday 26 February, is more than just a song and dance about Irish folklore. It’s a celebration of Ireland’s history…

  • Fencing reviews recommended

    Fencing reviews recommended

    FARMERS affected by the recent bushfires are being encouraged to review their infrastructure layout before re-establishing traditional fencing. For many fire-affected farmers, the rebuilding process provides the opportunity to establish…

  • New growth at grains conference

    New growth at grains conference

    THE next generation of farming practices is set to be on full display at Yarrawonga’s upcoming grains conference. The annual Grains Conference by Victorian Farmers Federation is a two-day event…

  • New manager for private hospital

    New manager for private hospital

    MILDURA Health Private Hospital has a new executive general manager. Sharita Ram, who has extensive clinical, operational, and executive leadership experience with private health and aged care, commenced her role…

  • Hay, check for weeds

    Hay, check for weeds

    DROUGHT and bushfire affected farmers are being encouraged to check their fodder deliveries for aggressive weeds that continue to threaten the State. The top concern is the parthenium weed, Parthenium…

  • Karly comes home for cancer concert

    Karly comes home for cancer concert

    WENTWORTH singer-songwriter, Karly Jewell, is on her way home to play at the 2026 Concert for Cancer Research at the Wentworth Showgrounds on Saturday, 7 March. Jewell, who has released…