Calling out offensive remarks

MILDURA is fortunate to boast a number of strong women in leadership positions.

Not just our state and federal MPs, Ali Cupper and Anne Webster, but in chief executive roles across some of our key community organisations. One of our top cops is Rebecca Olsen, Teresa Jayet has long been the respected boss at Mallee Family Care, Alison Walker is the head of intensive care who oversaw our COVID response at the hospital, the list goes on and on.

But let’s not kid ourselves, we still have a long way to go in terms of gender equality,

A Gannawarra Shire councillor this week made what were described as “horrifically misogynistic” Facebook comments after video emerged of Richmond footballer Dustin Martin touching a woman’s breast.

“I’d be more worried if he didn’t go in for a feel,” wrote Cr Garner Smith on a Yahoo post.

When the comment was met by some social media backlash, Smith responded: “To all you triggered, whinging, whining, bleating, bitching, offended losers, instead of getting a skinny soy latte with a twist of lemon, head to your local independent hardware store, buy a bag of cement and harden the #@&! up”.

But while most normal folk find such language appalling, some men still don’t.

In fact, some even took to our Facebook page to question why the councillor’s comments were an issue at all.

“Must be a slow news day,” one male reader wrote. “Councillor has an opinion. Wow … next,” wrote another man who seemingly has no issue with a community leader saying he’d be “more worried” if a man “didn’t go in for a feel” of a woman’s breast without permission.

Honestly, who are these people?

Sunraysia Daily approached Ms Cupper and another strong female leader in our community, Kim O’Reilly, for their responses to Cr Smith’s comments.

Kim, a domestic violence survivor, anti-violence crusader and 2022 Victoria Australian of the Year nominee, admitted she was “disgusted” that a community leader would hold women in such low regard.

“What example is he setting?,” she asked. “Men in power can do as they please, behave as they please?”

Ms Cupper, who held the gender equality portfolio when she was a Mildura councillor, said while it was important that women in leadership positions like herself had a voice on these issues, “a moment like this really calls for the blokes to step up”.

She is right, it’s on us men to be better.

So, as a middle-aged bloke who loves a beer and his footy, here goes:

Garner, I’ve never met you, but that you could in any way condone a man “going in for a feel” of a woman’s breast without consent is completely wrong, and, frankly creepy, irrespective of whether it was a strip club. It smacks of male entitlement no matter which way you frame it. Remember, too, this is a star footballer and role model to many young boys whose behaviour you are vindicating.

I don’t know if you are a father of daughters, or an uncle of nieces, but I am. And we as men should never accept that they be devalued or touched without their consent. I expect them to be respected always. We all should.

As Kim O’Reilly noted this week: “It’s NEVER ok to put your hands on someone else.”

So perhaps rather than telling us all to “harden the #@&! up” for calling you out on your comments, you could actually look in the mirror, and own your behaviour.

As Ali Cupper noted, there is nothing tough about those views, they are “sad and pathetic”.

If you can’t understand that, then perhaps enrol in a respect for women course and learn why such comments have no place in our society.

As a man, change starts with you.

Digital Editions


  • Annie’s Song at the arts centre

    Annie’s Song at the arts centre

    AUSSIE musician Darren Coggan has been a big fan of John Denver since seeing him live in Canberra when he was a teenager. The singer,…

More News

  • Peeps into the Past – 15 to 21 March: And the band played on

    Peeps into the Past – 15 to 21 March: And the band played on

    PRESENTED by Mildura & District Historical Society and compiled by Judi Hyde for Mildura Rural City Council Libraries. 100 YEARS AGO DIVER: Although much has been done to minimise the…

  • Deluge response ongoing

    Deluge response ongoing

    Cr Ali Cupper Mayor, Mildura Rural City Council THE recent rain and flood event has had a profound impact on many families, businesses, and primary producers across our municipality. For…

  • The great AI content heist

    The great AI content heist

    Paul Thomas Co-owner and managing director of Star News Group, Today News Group and SA Today IN a recent Australian Financial Review opinion piece, “There is nothing creative about AI…

  • Romance and suspense

    Romance and suspense

    THE library has wide range of large print adult fiction titles in the collection, with new items continually being added. Here is a selection of some of the new additions…

  • Trolley cartel rolls unchecked

    Trolley cartel rolls unchecked

    IS it just me, or is Mildura become the unofficial breeding ground for rogue shopping trolleys? They’re everywhere. Lurking in gutters, loitering under trees, making bold solo journeys down suburban…

  • Rain reveals Mildura’s true appeal

    Rain reveals Mildura’s true appeal

    THERE’S been plenty said about the “Tropical North Victoria” tourism push, but it’s only when the rain actually falls in Mildura that you realise the people behind the campaign might…

  • Yes to CCTV, no to travel

    Yes to CCTV, no to travel

    THE draft Wentworth Council Use of CCTV Policy will be adopted by the Shire following an exhibition period where no community feedback or comments were received. The policy outlines a…

  • Hunters hope for Easter eggs

    Hunters hope for Easter eggs

    EASTER Bunny is considering kids of all ages when preparing for the egg hunt at Cabarita’s Garden of Hope on Saturday 4 April. And there are plenty of beautiful gardens…

  • Golden donations

    Golden donations

    MILDURA residents can now donate plasma as well as whole blood following the latest refurbishments to Lifeblood’s Mildura Donor Centre. The expansion to the Mildura facility features three new chairs…

  • Grant apps now open

    Grant apps now open

    GRANTS of up to $20,000 are now available for grassroots projects aimed at supporting rural and regional communities, with applications open for the 2026 Elders Community Giving Project. Now in…