The Divided States of Australia

EVEN now, 18 months into the coronavirus pandemic, the only thing consistent about America’s approach to fighting the virus is that it continues to be wildly inconsistent.

One day, a city like Pittsburgh is cancelling its Labor Day Parade out of “an abundance of caution”, the next week it is staging a belated St Patrick’s Day party where big crowds gather en masse. One college football game allows 100,000-plus fans to pack in with no vaccine or mask mandate, while another a few kilometres down the road doesn’t let anyone in without proof of both.

The southern states are a different matter altogether.

There have already been 675,000 deaths in America, with predictions that they could get to 800,000 by the end of the year.

The issue, of course, is that the United States have never been “united” in the fight against COVID-19.

From state to state, the rules are dramatically different and the messaging from leaders continues to be mixed. From afar, it appears they still don’t know what they are doing.

But are we Australians really in a position to mock them?

Let’s face it, 18 months into this pandemic, can we really boast that we are presenting a united front as a country? Or do we look more divided than ever?

Right now, our state leaders are openly thumbing their noses at a national plan to reopen the country. From state to state, we continue to have Chief Health Officers delivering varying messages, and Premiers running their own agendas and making up their own rules as they go along.

These rules don’t need to make sense, nor do our Premiers feel the need to justify them with evidence.

The result is a battle-weary community, even broken in many parts, that remains far more confused and frustrated than they need to be this far into the pandemic.

The messaging needs to change. It has to change.

We need to bring this country together again and it starts with a consistent national approach that we all understand. That we all buy into.

The thing is, Australia is still in a very strong position in comparison to other countries.

We have proven over 18 months that we are not a reckless country, the overwhelming majority will follow rules to protect themselves and those around them.

And we are getting vaccinated at a much higher rate than other countries who have already opened up regardless.

As our country reopens, it needs to do so with rules and guidelines that we can respect and understand.

We can’t have, as we see here on the Victorian-NSW border, so many different restrictions on either side of a river, where one pub is able to operate at a profit and the other has to keep its doors shut, where some kids can go to school, but others can’t, where you are allowed or not allowed to play competitive sport depending which side of the map you are on.

As it stands, Australians could be flying overseas before the WA Premier Mark McGowan lets anyone into his state, with Qantas this week confirming it has cancelled most of its scheduled flights from WA to Victoria and NSW over summer and will reroute its direct Perth-London flights until at least April 2022.

We still don’t know at what vaccination rate we will be allowed into Queensland or South Australia, even Tasmania, or whether we will need to be fully vaccinated to get into a pub in Melbourne but not in Sydney.

We need to come together as a country with our approach to living with the virus, which will lead to better understanding of rules and help with future compliance. We must stop having states trying to get one-up on their political counterparts next door, and end what have become nasty and petty border wars. The politicians may get off on it, but it’s not who we mere mortal voters are.

Being divided in approach has not worked in the US.

It was 18 months ago where our leaders trumpeted the message: “We’re in it together” … Well, perhaps it is about time we were.”

Digital Editions


  • Chasing storms

    Chasing storms

    DARETON photographer Aaron Hawkins has captured the raw power of the Mallee, earning national recognition after chasing a fast-moving dust storm and turning it into…

More News

  • Harvest history at Red Cliffs

    Harvest history at Red Cliffs

    RED Cliffs has a long history of grape harvesting, starting after World War I when soldiers settled in the region, and has been going strong for over 75 years. The…

  • An inspiration to the end

    An inspiration to the end

    I always say you can learn a lot about a person by the way they behave between resigning from a job and actually leaving. That notice period is a good…

  • Reading large

    Reading large

    Mildura Rural City Council Libraries have added some new titles to the Large Print Collection that our readers may enjoy. Here is a selection for you to choose from. For…

  • Centenary train rolls into town

    Centenary train rolls into town

    Presented by Mildura and District Historical Society Compiled by Judy Hyde for Mildura Rural City Council Libraries 100 YEARS AGO – 1926 WATER- It is pointed out by Mr G…

  • Reduced winter wheat crop forecast

    Reduced winter wheat crop forecast

    RABOBANK has forecasted a reduced winter grain crop as producers try to plan ahead of weather conditions and operational costs. Rabobank’s RaboResearch recently released its annual Australian Winter Crop Forecast,…

  • Sri Lankan community welcomes new year

    Sri Lankan community welcomes new year

    MILDURA’S Sri Lankan community recently celebrated their new year, welcoming more than 100 families that now call the region home. The Mildura-based community has celebrated the Sri Lankan new year…

  • MRCC developing new arts strategy

    MRCC developing new arts strategy

    MILDURA Rural City Council has welcomed a highly regarded arts leader to develop the region’s new Arts and Culture Strategy. Former Creative Australia Chief Executive Officer Tony Grybowski was officially…

  • Ready to make noise and break things

    Ready to make noise and break things

    Raised on Pink Floyd and Deep Purple, Emily Tasci found her real home in the darker, louder world of Black Sabbath, punk and thrash metal. “I loved how unhinged the…

  • Cursing interrupts court

    Cursing interrupts court

    A MAN accused of shop theft, property damage, and breaching a family violence intervention order has had his bail application adjourned part-heard after he exploded in an expletive-filled rant at…

  • Museum doors fly open

    Museum doors fly open

    MILDURA’S Royal Australian Air Force Museum will open its doors this Sunday in an Open Day to celebrate its relocation. The RAAF’s relocation to an aircraft hangar at Mildura Airport…