Daily Matters: Border closures are a populist political tool

BY and large, Australians are a compliant lot.

Most of us like to do the right thing, particularly by each other.

Take our response to this pandemic and the draconian restrictions we have been asked to live by.

While younger generations may not necessarily fear dying from COVID-19, they understand the need to stop the spread and protect our elderly and vulnerable. The vast majority follow the rules for unselfish reasons, whether we agree with them all or not.

Never have pubs been a more civil environment. Never have people been more patient waiting in line for a coffee or a sandwich. We don’t even need the 1.5-metre markers on the floor to keep a safe distance away from the next customer.

It’s not the threat of fines that prevent us from crossing social boundaries, it’s become a healthy habit.

Our state governments need to better understand this and trust their own people as we learn to live with this virus.

An outbreak of cases in Adelaide this week has prompted fresh talks about the state border with Victoria, which is due to reopen on December 1.

South Australian Premier Steven Marshall has been ruthless in his approach with Victoria on the border issue throughout this pandemic, shutting out families from seeing each other, or medical specialists from flying to COVID-free regions like Mildura to help those in need. A friend from Mildura, who has been unable to afford 14 days’ quarantine, is still waiting to bury his mother, who died alone in Adelaide back in June.

But I do hope now that Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews doesn’t play tit-for-tat now that SA is fighting its own virus breakout.

The open-shut approach to internal borders can’t be the long-term solution to living with coronavirus in this country.

The border communities, in particular, have suffered immeasurably in both an economic and personal sense and need to be reconnected.

Over the past six months, Sunraysia Daily has told the stories of those who have been denied potentially life-saving surgery, to students being kept away from their parents due to the border closure.

Most of us in these parts view the border between SA and Victoria as an imaginary line in the sand, but instead it has been used as a populist political tool by a city-centric premier.

It needs to stop.

Too many people in Sunraysia are desperately waiting for the SA border to open to reconnect with families. We all have work colleagues and friends who have done it extremely tough during this time and we want to see them enjoying Christmas. Together.

How Australians have dealt with this virus is in stark contrast to countries like the United States, which remains so divided in its approach, largely due to Donald Trump’s leadership on the issue.

But I think part of Australia’s success is that we are not an overly self-righteous society. We are willing to sacrifice for the greater good. It’s why our gun laws dramatically changed after the Port Arthur massacre.

But governments need to be careful not to break that goodwill in the coronavirus fight.

They need to find a better balance, particularly in relation to dealing with future outbreaks and with border closures. If we are all indeed in this together, then the trust needs to go both ways.

Digital Editions


  • Lambing program yields productive results

    Lambing program yields productive results

    LATEST results from an on-farm Mallee demonstration have shown promising results for sheep producers looking to improve flock reproductive performance. The More Northern Mallee Lambs…

More News

  • Bail refused ram raid accused

    Bail refused ram raid accused

    THE alleged driver of a vehicle responsible for a ram raid at Titto’s Store earlier this week has been refused bail. The Mildura Magistrate’s Court heard Zach Whitelegg attended the…

  • Budget debt in heated debate

    Budget debt in heated debate

    VICTORIA’S operating surplus has become the topic of a heated enquiry following recent committee hearings into the budget estimates. The Victorian Government’s Public Accounts and Estimates Committee have recently launched…

  • Aged care protections too late: Webster

    Aged care protections too late: Webster

    MEMBER for Mallee Anne Webster has said the recently announced protections for aged care consumers is too little too late after Mallee residents are now waiting a reported 295 days…

  • Dig day discoveries at Mildura West

    Dig day discoveries at Mildura West

    PEOPLE driving past Mildura West Primary School on Wednesday might have thought that little diggers had mistaken the sand pit for an archaeological dig in Egypt. However, fossils, bones, artefacts…

  • RSPCA celebrates volunteer milestone

    RSPCA celebrates volunteer milestone

    RSPCA Victoria is celebrating its force of exceptional volunteers this National Volunteer Week (18-24 May) and recognising the essential role they play in animal welfare. As a gesture of thanks…

  • Rex reduction

    Rex reduction

    REX has announced a reduction in its return services between Mildura and Melbourne from 24 to 19 per week as part of a larger restructuring of its Victoria and Tasmania…

  • Eagles to swim it in at Sarah Oval

    Eagles to swim it in at Sarah Oval

    THE Imperials A Grade netball team will have to eat bucketfuls of Weetbix to try and beat Robinvale Euston at the Sarah Oval on Saturday. The Eagles, who are at…

  • Swallows to take flight

    Swallows to take flight

    ROUND seven sees Ouyen United play Irymple in the A Grade Sunraysia Football Netball League clash at Underbool Recreation Reserve on Saturday. It’s fourth versus eighth on the ladder, with…

  • Mildura still top responder

    Mildura still top responder

    MILDURA Ambulance Victoria response times have stayed close to average, reaching code one cases under 15 minutes more than 70 per cent of the time. Mildura’s Local Government Area cases…

  • Thirty cents a beer, I’ll drink to that

    Thirty cents a beer, I’ll drink to that

    PRESENTED by Mildura & District Historical Society Compiled by Mildura Rural City Council Libraries 100 YEARS AGO: 1926 PARCEL: Good progress is being made in the erection of the addition…